Fast company logo
|
advertisement

IMPACT

Bio-based plastic won’t solve the plastic problem

The Biden administration wants to replace 90% of plastic with bioplastic, but there are a lot of issues with that goal.

Bio-based plastic won’t solve the plastic problem

[Photos: lucafabbian/iStock/Getty Images Plus, art-i/iStock/Getty Images Plus, swillkitch/Getty Images]

BY Adele Peters4 minute read

If you order takeout in Los Angeles and your meal comes with a compostable fork made from PLA—a common bio-based plastic—you’re not supposed to toss the utensil in your curbside compost bin. The city doesn’t want any products or packaging labeled “biodegradable” or “compostable,” saying that the materials don’t actually break down quickly enough even at commercial composting facilities. The fork also can’t go in a recycling bin, since it can contaminate other materials. And if it ends up in a landfill or the ocean, it may last as long as if it had been made from regular plastic.

It’s one example of the challenges that face a new Biden administration goal to help the U.S. replace 90% of plastic with materials made from bio-based feedstocks.

“Bioplastic isn’t a silver bullet,” says Steve Hynd, policy and media manager for City to Sea, a UK nonprofit focused on plastic pollution. The first and most obvious step, he says, is using less plastic to begin with. Global plastic production doubled between 2000 to 2019. Since then, in the U.S. alone, more than 40 new petrochemical plants to make plastic have started construction or the permitting process.

The surge in plastic—around half of which is designed for a single use—isn’t just a waste problem, but a climate problem. (The new government goal is part of a broader plan to hit net-zero emissions by the middle of the century.) Most plastic is made from ethane, a byproduct of natural gas; 35 ethane “cracker” facilities in the U.S. release around 70 million tons of greenhouse gas emissions a year, according to a 2021 report from Beyond Plastics. Other chemical feedstocks and additives in plastic add even more emissions to the final product. The report calculated that the plastic industry in the U.S. could outpace pollution from the country’s coal power plants by the end of this decade.

Depending on how it’s made, bio-based plastic could help significantly shrink that footprint. One new bottled water brand, for example, uses compostable bioplastic made with food waste (the material, called PHA, also has a lower footprint than other bio-based feedstocks like sugarcane or corn, and is designed to break down more easily than some other compostables). But it still makes more sense to focus on refillable and reusable packaging, argues Melissa Valliant, communications director for Beyond Plastics. “We’ve used [refillables and reusables] in the past,” she says. “We’ve seen them in other countries being used by businesses and companies very successfully. And those have a much smaller climate impact than anything that’s disposable, because it’s being reused over and over again.”

While increasing reuse is important, bio-based alternatives still make sense for some applications, says Pierre Paslier, cofounder of the startup Notpla, which has developed a seaweed-based film that can replace the plastic film used in sachets that hold cosmetics or food, as well as other packaging. Under European definitions, the new material isn’t considered plastic, because it hasn’t been chemically modified; instead, a natural polymer is extracted from the seaweed. It can break down in compost more quickly than a fruit peel, Paslier says.

“Compostable packaging should be as compostable as food waste,” he says. “It shouldn’t require more time and more energy and more special considerations.”

Still, right now, the startup’s packaging wouldn’t be allowed in Los Angeles’s compost bins. And the same is true for most American cities that offer curbside composting. Even some cities that processed compostable packaging in the past are phasing it out. Denver is one of the latest to say that it will no longer accept “certified compostable” packaging in its compost bins. For compostable packaging to work, the bigger system will need to change. Some bio-based materials can also be recycled, while others can’t, creating more confusion for both consumers and recyclers. The best-intentioned materials are likely to end up in landfills or even join the 11 million tons of plastic waste that enter the ocean each year.

The right infrastructure for reusable packaging also doesn’t yet exist, though we’re slowly beginning to move in that direction. The U.K., for example, has services like Milk & More, a milkman-style grocery delivery company that brings products in refillable packaging; the U.S. has similar startups like The Rounds. “We are at a stage where there’s lots of pilots happening, lots of trials happening,” Hynd says. “And I think part of the problems of trials is that they are, by definition, done on a small scale. And we know for economies of scale, we need things to be really taking off.”

The U.S. should also push for a strong global plastics treaty, says Valliant, with a cap on plastic production and an emphasis on reuse and refill. And Congress could reconsider new legislation like the Break Free from Plastic Pollution Act that was introduced last year. “It was a perfect example of a comprehensive approach to the problem—not just looking at how to manage plastic waste once consumers are finished with it, but looking at the upstream solutions of trying to stop plastic pollution at the source by reducing production as well,” she says. “We’re not going to effectively combat this crisis if that’s not part of the plan.”

Recognize your company's culture of innovation by applying to this year's Best Workplaces for Innovators Awards before the final deadline, April 5.

ModernCEO Newsletter logo
A refreshed look at leadership from the desk of CEO and chief content officer Stephanie Mehta
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.
Privacy Policy

ABOUT THE AUTHOR

Adele Peters is a senior writer at Fast Company who focuses on solutions to climate change and other global challenges, interviewing leaders from Al Gore and Bill Gates to emerging climate tech entrepreneurs like Mary Yap. She contributed to the bestselling book "Worldchanging: A User's Guide for the 21st Century" and a new book from Harvard's Joint Center for Housing Studies called State of Housing Design 2023 More


Explore Topics