advertisement
advertisement

Inside the complicated paradox of building concrete sea walls

The concrete breakwaters designed to protect people from the consequences of global warming also contribute to it. It’s time to start using different materials.

Inside the complicated paradox of building concrete sea walls
[Photo: Ferran Vega/Getty Images]

The Tōhoku earthquake of 2011 remains the strongest in recorded Japanese history. It created a tsunami that towered over 40 meters and dismantled coastal flood defenses in northeastern Japan with ease, taking the lives of around 16,000 people.

advertisement
advertisement

Japanese authorities, wanting to better protect communities in future, chose to build bigger defenses. Concrete walls that span 400km and reach nearly 15 meters high in places now line the coast to resist incoming waves and allow enough time for residents to evacuate in the event of another tsunami.

They were recently tested by a 7.4 magnitude earthquake, which struck off the coast of the Fukushima prefecture on March 16 2022, killing at least four people and injuring many more. Mercifully, the resulting tsunami was negligible compared with that of 11 years prior.

These sea walls will also serve as a defensive frontline against the effects of climate change. A recent report by the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change found that even in the best case, where the world halts warming at 1.5°C, sea levels could rise by 0.55 meters on average globally by 2100. This could lead to crippling storm surges in many places.

advertisement
advertisement

Paradoxically, these walls which are designed to protect people from the consequences of global heating also contribute to it. We estimated the emissions involved in creating northeastern Japan’s concrete breakwaters at around six million tonnes of CO₂ by taking into account their size and length and using industry-standard tools.

A reinforced coastal dike in north-eastern Japan, built following the 2011 tsunami. [Photo:Ravindra Jayaratne/courtesy of the authors]
So how can countries build stronger sea walls without making climate change worse? Following post-tsunami surveys of damaged breakwaters in southern Sri Lanka (2004) and north-eastern Japan (2011) with colleagues at Waseda University, and drawing from the University of East London’s low-carbon concrete research, we may have found an answer.

Low-carbon concrete

Concrete is the most common material for making breakwaters. Cement, the main binder in a concrete mix, is primarily made of clinker – a residue produced by firing limestone and clay in a furnace heated to 14,500°C. Creating that much heat is typically done by burning fossil fuels, emitting greenhouse gases in the process.

advertisement

Cement making is responsible for about 7% of annual CO₂ emissions. But without concrete, many of the world’s most impressive buildings and structures – such as Australia’s Sydney Opera House and the Hoover Dam in Las Vegas – wouldn’t exist. One of the biggest challenges facing the construction sector is reducing concrete’s carbon footprint while keeping the benefits of a cheap and durable building material.

One way to achieve this is by replacing cement with recycled industrial waste, such as granulated slag from steelworks and pulverized ash from coal power plants (essentially, the residue that can be scraped out of the bottom of furnaces).

Our newly designed low-carbon concrete mixes use both of these recycled materials. In fact, it was possible to use up to 60% steel furnace waste in the mixes without the concrete losing its compressive strength, which is crucial for ensuring the structure holds up. The resulting mixes had a 40% smaller carbon footprint than traditional concrete.

advertisement

Our designs also use steel fibers akin to hairpins that can be added to the concrete mix, eliminating the need to assemble vast steel mesh grids. The costs and emissions of construction are lower as a result, and the final product is just as strong as a traditional breakwater.

Working with nature

Concrete breakwaters can even stimulate biodiversity. Some are textured in such a way that they mimic reef habitats, encouraging the settlement and growth of marine plants and animals in their grooves and protruding surfaces.

This concrete recreates the shape and texture of coral and other reef species. [Photo: Sensicon/courtesy of the authors]
Over time, even the best-designed breakwaters will crack. Miraculously, engineers have developed self-healing concrete that uses microorganisms capable of producing limestone to autonomously repair these structures. The idea of living organisms weaving through and repairing concrete, a material usually considered cold and lifeless, is very exciting to us.

advertisement

There are likely to be even more sustainable concrete designs in the future, as 3D printing allows us to create more efficient patterns that use less material and produce less waste.

Using less to build more may worry coastal communities which live in fear of tsunamis, as sustainable breakwaters are likely to be thinner, smaller and curved instead of straight. Yet these structures are just as strong and show that the world can adapt to the effects of climate change without making it worse.

Ravindra Jayaratne is a reader in coastal engineering at the University of East London and Ali Abbas is an associate professor of structural engineering at the University of East London. This article is republished from The Conversation under a Creative Commons license. Read the original article.

advertisement
advertisement
!-- Below is The Conversation's page counter tag. Please DO NOT REMOVE. -->The Conversation