advertisement
advertisement

The GOP failed to make Amy Coney Barrett’s notepad an effective prop. Here’s why

An attempt to highlight the Supreme Court justice nominee’s smarts only served to highlight a huge disparity.

The GOP failed to make Amy Coney Barrett’s notepad an effective prop. Here’s why
[Photo: Tom Williams-Pool/Getty Images]

Rarely is an empty gesture so literally empty.

advertisement
advertisement

Early on into the second day of the hearing portion of Amy Coney Barrett’s Ford v Ferrari-speed confirmation process, GOP Senator John Cornyn of Texas asked the nominee to lift up her notepad.

The revelation that followed fell decidedly short of what magicians call “the Prestige.”

It remains unclear how “look ma, no notes!” is intended to convey superior smarts rather than an absence of preparation or seriousness, although the Trump-era GOP clearly considers no theatrics too eye roll-y to put in front of people’s eyeballs.

Fellow Republicans Lindsey Graham and Jim Jordan used the last Supreme Court justice confirmation hearing, for instance, to take turns screaming about how galled they were over Democrats’ insistence on . . . investigating a credible accusation of sexual misconduct against the nominee.

In less heated settings, such as last November’s impeachment inquiry against Trump, Congress members tend to practice a less emphatic form of stunt: signage. The GOP in that instance filled the space with poster boards touting esoteric ephemera (“95 days since Schiff learned the identity of the whistleblower”) while insisting the entire process was a sham.

advertisement

Democrats have boasted a similar reliance on visual aids during Barrett’s confirmation hearing. However, their usage has been more elegant. Monday’s hearing involved a parade of poster boards featuring images and testimonials of people who will be affected by striking down Obamacare, which many fear Barrett will vote to do if confirmed. These images underscored the Dems’ laser focus on the topic of healthcare that day.

On Tuesday, Democratic Senator Sheldon Whitehouse of Rhode Island used a series of miniature poster boards to walk viewers through an engaging, data-rich presentation on the behind-the-scenes machinations that appear to have played a role in Barrett’s nomination.

In response, Republican Senator Marsha Blackburn of Tennessee ignored the actual facts of Whitehouse’s presentation and instead applied his focus on “dark money” to revive the anti-Semitism-tinged conspiracy theory that left-leaning billionaire George Soros funds every form of activism the GOP doesn’t care for.

The difference in approaches only further highlights the GOP’s reliance on the pageantry of make-believe during this confirmation hearing.

advertisement

They are pretending that their Democrat colleagues are making the hearing a referendum on Barrett’s Catholicism, when that is demonstrably not the case.

They are pretending that Barrett’s position on Roe v Wade isn’t already known; that she might be neutral on this extremely controversial and contentious issue.

And they are pretending that Barrett’s supposed eminent qualifications are the reason they’re going full speed ahead in her confirmation, despite the fact that COVID-19 relief should clearly be a higher priority in Congress, and the brazen hypocrisy of rushing an election-year confirmation after everything Mitch McConnell has said about depriving President Obama of the same opportunity.

When Amy Coney Barrett held up that blank notepad, she might as well have been holding up a list of compelling reasons for this process’s legitimacy.

advertisement
advertisement