Man Who Threatened His Wife On Facebook Gets Supreme Court Date http://www.fastcompany.com/3031977/fast-feed/supreme-court-to-consider-case-of-man-who-made-threats-on-facebook by @AliceTruong via @FastCompany
Click here to preview the new Fast Company

Want to try out the new FastCompany.com?

If you’d like to return to the previous design, click the yellow button on the lower left corner.

Man Who Threatened His Wife On Facebook Gets Supreme Court Date

What constitutes a threat: the perpetrator's subjective intent or another person's objective interpretation?

In a case that will have broad implications for social media posts, the Supreme Court has agreed to hear the appeal of Anthony Elonis, a Pennsylvania man sentenced to nearly four years in federal prison for threatening remarks he made online toward his wife, an FBI agent, and former coworkers.

When Elonis stood trial in 2010, a lower federal court rejected the claim his comments were protected by the First Amendment. Elonis, who said he was depressed when his wife of seven years left him, maintained that he never intended to carry out his threats, which took the form of rap lyrics posted to Facebook.

"Did you know that it's illegal for me to say I want to kill my wife?" he wrote in one of his posts. "It's illegal. It's indirect criminal contempt. It's one of the only sentences that I'm not allowed to say."

At the heart of the debate is the question of what constitutes a threat: the perpetrator's subjective intent or another person's objective interpretation. Objective interpretation was the jury's basis for convicting Elonis, who has since completed his 44-month prison sentence.

According to a recent poll surveying 1,007 Americans, 62% of Internet users who were harassed online said it happened on Facebook, and more than two-thirds said they knew their online assailants in real life.

[Image: Flickr user Mark Fischer]

Add New Comment

1 Comments

  • Audrey Byers

    Who says white powers don't work? i was an unbeliever of it not until it worked for me, i condemn those things until situation forced me to give a try and right now i have found myself convincing others too. i just realised we have to faith it in life to make it.my woman was enchanted away by a so called friend whom i accomodated in our home, both of them dissapeared from our home and went to settle down in maschutte on June 24th . I tried convincing my love back into my life but she turned deaf ear to all i said and even hit me at a time. Sent several emails which she ignored not until i contacted this psychic whom i saw a brief story about him on a tabloid and his powers, tried him with little faith and because i really love my woman. i was guaranteed just 3 days and towards the exact time she will get back home to me. Heaven knows i really dont know how or what they did but it worked for me even though i am a christain by religion this things work and i believe they are still descen