Tech Companies Including Google, Facebook, And Zynga Unite Against The Patenting Of Abstract Ideas

Eight tech firms are asking the U.S. Justice system to reject lawsuits based on vague concepts, saying that the costly process stifles innovation.

Tech Companies Including Google, Facebook, And Zynga Unite Against The Patenting Of Abstract Ideas

An octet of tech companies have filed an amicus brief asking the courts to reject lawsuits concerning vague patent concepts. Facebook, Google, Zynga, Red Hat, Intuit, Dell, Homeaway, and Rackspace are all saying that abstract claims–for example, the Steve Jobs patent, rejected by the U.S. patent office on Friday, which attempted to claim ownership of any multi-touch interface–are a waste of money and suffocate innovation.

The short-term aim of the brief is to upend a recent decision by the courts to uphold the Alice Corp’s patent claim on computer-implemented financial intermediation over the CLS Bank (translation: the bank creates a “shadow” site, usually in data storage, on which credits and debits can be made. When the transaction is completed–i.e., the person sending the money is found to have enough funds in his account–on the shadow site, then the demand is made to the real site belonging to the financial institution).

The argument put forward by Google, Facebook, and the rest, says this: “It is easy to think of abstract ideas about what a computer or website should do, but the difficult, valuable, and often groundbreaking part of online innovation comes next: designing, analyzing, building, and deploying the interface, software and hardware to implement that idea in a way that is useful in daily life. Simply put, ideas are much easier to come by than working implementations.”

[Image from an earlier attempt to patent the interactive web, defeated by Google, Amazon, and Yahoo]

About the author

My writing career has taken me all round the houses over the past decade and a half--from grumpy teens and hungover rock bands in the U.K., where I was born, via celebrity interviews, health, tech and fashion in Madrid and Paris, before returning to London, where I now live. For the past five years I've been writing about technology and innovation for U.S.



More Stories