Ken O'Brien was an NFL quarterback in the 1980s and 1990s. Early in his career, he threw a lot of interceptions, so one clever team lawyer wrote a clause into O'Brien's contract penalizing him for each one he threw. The incentive worked as intended: His interceptions plummeted. But that's because he stopped throwing the ball.
Years ago, AT&T executives tried to encourage productivity by paying programmers based on the number of lines of code they produced. The result: programs of Proustian length.
Incentives are dangerous, and not just because people game them. They often yield collateral damage. Remember the tale of the Darwin Award winner who strapped a jet engine to his car, dreaming of a joyride for the ages, and then met his sorry end as a human flapjack on the side of a mountain? Incentives are like that jet engine. There's no question the engine will take you somewhere, fast, but it's not always clear where. Or what you're going to mow down on the way. Yet incentives are still the first resort of most managers, perhaps because they all think they're smart enough to create the perfect carrot.
Take Merrill Lynch. In the book Riding the Bull, author Paul Stiles describes his experience as a new trader at the venerable investment bank. Merrill wanted Stiles, then 29, to trade complex international bonds in volatile markets. He tried asking advice of the seasoned traders, but they ignored him -- a minute spent helping Stiles was a minute spent not adding to their monthly bonuses. They kept barking into their phones for hours at a time and yelled at Stiles every time his shadow fell across their computer screens. Eventually, Stiles was reduced to silently observing their behavior from a distance, like a rogue MBA anthropologist. It surely never dawned on the person who set up Merrill Lynch's incentive system that the traders' bonuses would make training new employees impossible.
Why are we so bad at anticipating the effects of our well-intentioned incentive plans? The answer has to do with something that psychologists call a "focusing illusion." Behavioral economist Daniel Kahneman and management professor David Schkade surveyed Midwestern students and asked them to predict the satisfaction of students in California on several dimensions, such as "job prospects," "climate," "personal safety," and overall life satisfaction. They also asked the Midwesterners to rate their own satisfaction. The professors then posed the same questions to actual California students and compared the answers. The Midwest students correctly predicted that the Californians would be happier about their weather.
But the Midwestern students wrongly predicted that California students would be happier with their lives in general than Midwestern students. The overall scores are identical. Schkade and Kahneman showed that, in essence, the Midwestern students erred by focusing too much on a single variable. When you're a Midwesterner contemplating a long, cold winter, you can't help but think that Californians must be happier. But you're ignoring the larger happiness portfolio, in which weather recedes to insignificance among the other things that may influence a Californian's satisfaction -- good friends, terrible traffic, career opportunities, laundry, and a governor who compulsively repeats Terminator jokes.
Focusing illusions even distort our judgments about ourselves. In another study, some college students were asked, "How happy are you?" and then "How many dates did you have last month?" The researchers found a pretty weak correlation between the level of happiness and the number of dates. But then (hilariously) the researchers flipped the order of the two questions. Suddenly, there was a strong correlation. Having just confessed to a lack of dates, students reported that their lives were joyless.
And this brings us back to the incentive puzzle. When the football team's lawyer hatched a plan to minimize O'Brien's interceptions, he was suffering from a focusing illusion. He reduced the world to a one-variable equation, like a college student fretting about his flatlining dating life.
To be fair, there are some contexts where one variable dominates. If you're employing a field sales rep who is selling a simple, self-contained product, then it probably makes sense to tie incentives to the sale. If you're traveling a long, straight road, the jet engine will get you there faster.
But chances are you don't live in a one-variable world. In your complicated, squishy, matrixed world, if you're dreaming up an incentive plan, you're almost certainly in the grips of a focusing illusion. You're trying to maximize or optimize or minimize something. And you may unwittingly find that when you maximize the length of your programmer's code, you end up minimizing your job tenure.
Email
Digg
StumbleUpon
Facebook
Buzz Up!
LinkedIn
Recent Comments | 21 Total
January 26, 2009 at 8:15am by Raymond Durrant
Exactly right. I don't know about other areas of business, but there is an epidemic of these problems in the world of engineering. Another related problem is focussing on variables which are easily quantified at the expense of those which are not: e.g. It's difficult to quantify loss from poor customer service or benefits from improved staff training, but it's easy to measure the costs and benefits of improving a manufacturing process. Therefore it's much easier to build a business case, and secure a budget, for the latter.
January 26, 2009 at 10:49am by Darin Phillips
Kaplan and Norton's balanced score card can be applied to individual contributors to prevent the myopic problems that you have highlighted in this article. A decent performance management consultant will always tease out the various ways to defeat the incentive system and build in safeguards that create a well-rounded view of performance to be rewarded.
Merrill Lynch should not want their traders to take time out of the day to train a new hire. That responsibility should fall on the person who is incentivized to ensure that new hires succeed, the boss of the new hire. However, the Ken O'Brien story is very interesting.
January 26, 2009 at 10:54am by Darin Phillips
Kaplan and Norton's balanced score card can be applied to individual contributors to prevent the myopic problems that you have highlighted in this article. A decent performance management consultant will always tease out the various ways to defeat the incentive system and build in safeguards that create a well-rounded view of performance to be rewarded.
Merrill Lynch should not want their traders to take time out of the day to train a new hire. That responsibility should fall on the person who is incentivized to ensure that new hires succeed, the boss of the new hire. However, the Ken O'Brien story is very interesting.
January 28, 2009 at 1:31pm by Denzel Eslinger
Horrible Advice, Anything can be used incorrectly and the examples they give are classics. It is not the duty of current workers to train new hires, that is the responsibilty of HR and training departments. Expecting that a sales person would stop selling to train is a recipe for disaster, sales people are hired to sell.
Good incentives are ones that reward behaviors as well as results, in the O'Brien example a good incentive would have been rewarding him for a higher percentage of completions. A good incentive would never be tied to a negative behavior, sorry guys you are just out of touch with this one.
Incentives lead to higher productivty and better results than not using incentives, you might want to check the research done by Scott Jeffery on the topic.
Please stop trying to create headlines by generalizing things it is clear are not within your realm of knowledge, stick to what you know.
February 2, 2009 at 12:55am by Matt van Wyk
I do not often comment in these forums, but sometimes advice offered necessitates a word or two. Hopefully we have young professionals reading these articles to become a little wiser, or get an idea they want to experiment with. This places some level of responsibility on our shoulders to steer behaviours towards an improved level of performance potential, and not make wild statements which could potentially destroy value in the hands of those less experienced. I like the article; it is practical and touches on an issue all organisations have been struggling with at some stage. The comment made by a reader that training of new employees by current employees is absurd, is one of these reckless comments detracting from the good work in the article. Behind the success of many organisations lies the fact that current workers differentiate themselves by excelling in two areas: problem solving and coaching/training (Toyota et. al.). Yes, HR can prepare the worker for training, but without the experts (which the current workers hopefully are!) departing their knowledge to new employees, how can an organisation stay ahead of the pack? Line management and current workers MUST surely play a leading role? Selling, for instance, is only a part of a “whole job”, which (as Kaplan and Norton advocates) have many more aspects. A part of their job should be to train new employees. In great companies every employee transfers his best knowledge to ensure sustainability. Hats off to the Heaths! The topic needs much more research and debate.
February 8, 2009 at 2:33pm by glenn parker
It should be of concern that most of the article's conclusions are based on studies using college students as subjects rather than those that focused on business incentives. The Merrill Lynch story is an example of bad incentive. In another Merrill example, the company tried to change the culture in the retail area from an excessive focus on trading (sometimes called "churning") to one that emphasized financial planning with clients - in other words, having financial planners invest time with their clients developing a long-term financial plan. The incentive plan was simple - the more plans you created (using a specific template), the greater your reward. It was a win-win-win for client, company and the financial planner. In the end, a reward plan simply says "do this, get that." for example, if you deliver this software with these specs, the whole team will get $$. We produced more than 20 such case studies of effective rewards and recognition programs in our book, Rewarding Teams: Lessons from the Trenches. Incentives can work but only with careful planning.
February 8, 2009 at 2:33pm by glenn parker
It should be of concern that most of the article's conclusions are based on studies using college students as subjects rather than those that focused on business incentives. The Merrill Lynch story is an example of bad incentive. In another Merrill example, the company tried to change the culture in the retail area from an excessive focus on trading (sometimes called "churning") to one that emphasized financial planning with clients - in other words, having financial planners invest time with their clients developing a long-term financial plan. The incentive plan was simple - the more plans you created (using a specific template), the greater your reward. It was a win-win-win for client, company and the financial planner. In the end, a reward plan simply says "do this, get that." for example, if you deliver this software with these specs, the whole team will get $$. We produced more than 20 such case studies of effective rewards and recognition programs in our book, Rewarding Teams: Lessons from the Trenches. Incentives can work but only with careful planning.
February 13, 2009 at 9:16pm by William Seidman
This article is right on the money! We have broad experience with many companies in both the private and public sectors and the incentive programs tend to harm productivity and success more than they help. We have found the best motivator is linking work to a contribution to a holistic, greater social good, and aligning the incentives with that social good. People are far more motivated by a meaningful contribution than by money, even financially driven sales people. Make the social goal clear, tie the work to the goal, and incent achieving the goal, and productivity soars.
July 16, 2009 at 3:06am by Smith William
A part of their job should be to train new employees.MBA degree In great companies every employee transfers his best knowledge to ensure sustainability. Hats off to the Heaths! The topic needs much more research and debate.teaching degree
July 16, 2009 at 3:08am by Smith William
it is practical and touches on an issue all organisations have been struggling with at some stage.home school The comment made by a reader that training of new employees by current employees is absurd.home school curriculum | GED Online
September 14, 2009 at 2:40am by kagy helen
MOD Converter MOD Converter, as a professional conversion software,Can convert MOD to almost all the video formats support by PC,such as AVI,MPEG,MOV,WMV.The best MOD Converter also support Convert MOD to DVD,Blu Ray HD formats Devices.In additong,you also can use MOD converter to convert MOD to iPod ,iPhone,MP4,mobile phone and so on.Ok,now let's know more Features about the Emicsoft MOD Converter.
September 16, 2009 at 12:46pm by medy pharm
Health and fitness is always a person's prime concern today's hectic lifestyle and fast-paced society.
online pharmacy
October 28, 2009 at 1:09am by jessic smith
Besides the ready profiles, MOD Converter also allows you to adjust all video and audio encoding setting, like video resolution, frame rate, audio bitrate, sample rate, etc.MOD File Converter ,You can convert all popular video and audio formats to AMV files, such as:AMV Converter
November 10, 2009 at 3:42am by hqconverter hqconverter
DVD Video Copier (DVD Copier) is the best DVD to DVD copier tool, that can copy DVD to DVD, such as copy DVD 5 to DVD 5, copy DVD 9 to DVD 9, shrink DVD 9 to DVD 5, and copy DVD to ISO image file or DVD folder to be stored on computer, it also helps burn DVD folder or ISO files to DVD disk.
November 15, 2009 at 10:19pm by bodom bodom
M4R Converter Mac, a smart iPhone ringtone maker and uploader, provides an all-in-one iPhone Ringtone solution for Apple Mac users. With this Mac M4R Converter, you can create your own M4R iPhone ringtones from all mainstream audio files such as purchased songs, itunes music and MP3, WMA, AAC, WAV, OGG, M4A, RA, RAM, AC3, MP2. It can also extract m4r ringtone from all video files including AVI, MPEG, WMV, DivX, MP4, H.264/AVC, AVCHD, MKV, RM, MOV, XviD, 3GP.
m4r converter is also a M4R maker software, which is designed to convert video and audio files of any format to M4R file which can be directly set as iPhone ringtone. For example, it helps convert MP3 to M4R, AAC to M4R, M4A to M4R. If you are looking for a free MP3 to M4R converter for iPhone ringtones, please have a try with this one.
MP3 to M4R Converter is a perfect mp3 to m4r converter for iphone ringtones. It is easy and direct to convert mp3 ringtones to m4r and upload to iPhone directly. Delete iPhone Ringtone feature is added.
M4R to MP3 Converter is an excellent m4r to mp3 converter. It will assist iPhone users to convert M4R to MP3 format. The M4R can be iTunes iPhone ringtone music which are protected M4R, and also can be unprotected M4R created from some iPhone Ringtone Maker programs.
With the development of digital products, convert m4a to m4r for iPhone Ringtone is very popolar in iPhone users. M4A to M4R Converter is the best assistant to make ringtone for your iPhone, iPhone (3G) from your own video and audio sources.
AAC to M4R Converter is a strong and effortless aac to m4r converting tool. With AAC to M4R Converter, you can convert aac to m4r with super high speed and excellent output quality.
iPhone Ringtone Converter is an useful converter, it not only can convert audio to iPhone ringtone, such as WAV, MP3 etc, but also can convert AVI, MPEG, WMV, DivX, MP4,etc. to iPhone ringtone.
iPhone Ringtone Creator is specially designed for iPhone users who want to create your own special iPhone ringtone.
November 18, 2009 at 4:05am by bodom bodom
QuickTime Converter for Mac, known as Mac quicktime converter, has powerful function of converting between all conventional video and audio formats, such as MP4, MOV, AVI, MKV, Divx, MPEG-1/2, 3GP, 3G2, VOB etc. What's more, the Mac quicktime mov converter can also convert video to audio formats, such as MP3, AAC, AC3 and so on.
Have you ever dreamed of making movies by yourself? If you want to realize the beautiful dream, let me show you the wonderful tool---QuickTime Movie Converter for Mac. The quicktime converter for Mac can convert all different formats of movie, such as MP4, MOV, AVI, MKV, Divx, MPEG-1/2, 3GP, 3G2, VOB etc. Furthermore, with the help of quicktime media converter os x, you could edit the video files according to your own need.
QuickTime File Converter for Mac, is the multifunctional file converter quicktime for mac, which can perfectly convert all popular video and audio files between AVI, MP4, MOV, MKV, WMV, DivX, XviD, MPEG-1/2, 3GP, 3G2, VOB Video, MP3, AAC, and AC3 Audio etc. Not only can it convert QuickTime files, but edit perfectly the files for you.
Convert QuickTime to MP3 for Mac, as the literal meaning, can convert QuickTime to MP3 for Mac. In fact, its functions are far more than this. The file converter quicktime to MP3, can also convert between almost all video and audio files on Mac, such as AVI, MP4, MOV, MKV, WMV, DivX, XviD, MPEG-1/2, 3GP, 3G2, VOB Video, MP3, AAC, and AC3 Audio etc. So it's really very easy for the software to convert QuickTime to MP3.
Convert QuickTime to MPEG for Mac, also known as Mac QuickTime to MPEG converter, is professionally designed for Mac users. It can convert QuickTime to MPEG for Mac quickly with high quality.
Convert QuickTime to AVI for Mac, is an excellent software which could convert QuickTime to AVI for Mac. The Mac QuickTime to AVI converter offers the most robust and progressive function not only to convert QuickTime to AVI for Mac, but to convert almost all video and audio files on Mac, such as MP4, MOV, MKV, WMV, DivX, XviD, MPEG-1/2, 3GP, 3G2, VOB and HD Video (TS, MTS, M2TS), MP3, AAC, and AC3 Audio etc.
Convert QuickTime to WMV for Mac is a all-in-one Mac QuickTime to WMV converter, which has abundant functions. The most basic one is to convert QuickTime to WMV, with fast conversion speed and amazing output quality.
Convert QuickTime to MP4 for Mac, which is an ideal, simple-to-use and popular video converter for Mac users, can easily and quickly convert QuickTime to MP4 for mac with high output quality.
November 20, 2009 at 2:26am by bodom bodom
iPhone 3G Ringtone Maker, the best ringtone maker expert, enables you to make whatever ringtone you like. The powerful 3G iPhone ringtone maker, can convert a variety of video and audio formats like AVI, MPEG, WMV, MP4, FLV, MKV, H.264/MPEG-4, DivX, XviD, MOV, RM, RMVB, MP3, WMA, AAC to iPhone Ringtone M4R and transfer to iPhone directly without iTunes.
The iPhone 3G Ringtone Maker for Mac, professionally designed for Mac users, can create all kinds of ringtone for iPhone owners. If you are one of the owners, the iphone 3g ringtone maker for mac is the best choice for you to make dulcet and unique ringtone by yourself.
With the iPhone Ringtone Converter 3G, you are allowed to clip any segment of the video or audio files and convert it to iPhone. It's a good idea to clip the most wonderful part and convert it to iphone 3g ringtone. Using the software, you are free to edit the added iPhone ringtone by removing it or renaming it directly. Besides, it is very easy to operate. All you need to do is just a few clicks to convert iphone 3g ringtones.
With 3G iPhone Ringtone Creator, you will be able to select any video and audio files, including AVI, MPEG, WMV, MP4, FLV, MKV, H.264/MPEG-4, DivX, XviD, MOV, RM, RMVB, MP3, WMA, AAC and transform it into 3G iPhone Ringtone. What's more, you can also choose any part of the song you want.
iPhone 3G M4R Converter, also known as M4R converter for iPhone 3G, is an excellent software to convert almost all video and audio formats to M4R formats. The powerful input video and audio formats are beyond your imagination, such as, AVI, MPEG, WMV, MP4, FLV, MKV, H.264/MPEG-4, DivX, XviD, MOV, RM, RMVB, MP3, WMA, AAC etc.
Convert MP3 to iPhone 3G Ringtone is professionally designed for iPhone 3G users. It can not only convert mp3 formats to iphone 3g ringtone with ease but can convert a wide range of video and audio files, including AVI, MPEG, WMV, MP4, FLV, MKV, H.264/MPEG-4, DivX, XviD, MOV, RM, RMVB, WMA, AAC to M4R files that could be used as the ringtone.
M4A to iPhone 3G Ringtone Converter is designed specially to convert M4A to iPhone ringtone. Besides, it can also convert the other audio formats, such as MP3, WMA, AAC etc. to M4R as the ringtone for iPhone 3G. So you can use it not only to convert M4A to iPhone 3G ringtone, but also can easily convert your favorite MP3 or WMA songs to M4r as your ringtone.
Most people get their favorite ringtone by paying on the Internet every month. But now, we have an excellent creator which could free provide you any ringtone you want. The creator is MP4 to iPhone 3G Ringtone Converter.
November 20, 2009 at 2:30am by bodom bodom
MKV Converter is the best mkv video converter software that created to help you convert mkv video files to MP4/MKV/WMV/AVI and other popular formats such as: MP4, H.264, AVI, MP3, WMV, WMA, FLV, MKV, MPEG-1, MPEG-2, 3GP, 3GPP, VOB, DivX, Mov, RM, RMVB, M4A, AAC, WAV, etc with high speed and excellent sound/image quality.
MKV Converter is powerful and useful MKV Converter that make you Convert MKV File a enjoy thing, it is produced to help you convert MKV file to MP4, H.264, AVI, MP3, WMV, WMA, FLV, MKV, MPEG-1, MPEG-2, 3GP, 3GPP, VOB, DivX, Mov, RM, RMVB, M4A, AAC, WAV, etc with high speed and excellent sound/image quality.
With MKV Converter, you can conveniently Convert Video to MKV as well as crop the play region or cut any part of the video into MKV(Matroska Video) video clips by setting up the start and end time after preview. While the image quality is high, the conversion speed is very fast.
MKV Converter for Mac is a excellent Mac MKV Converter. This versatile MKV Converter Mac can convert between MKV and all popular video, HD video and audio formats with super fast conversion speed and satisfied output quality. In addition, the MKV converter for Mac can also extract audio from video file and convert video to MP3, AC3, and AAC… as you want.
MKV Video Converter is the Best Video Converter software that invented to help you convert MKV to AVC H264 with high speed and excellent sound/image quality.
MKV to HD Video is designed to convert .bdmv and m2ts file, it can convert the BDMV files to MKV format. BDMV folder and .bdmv files are mostly seen in the Blu-ray disc (BD) content and AVCHD video folder. There usually is a index.bdmv file in the root directory, while BDMV folder contains video, audio, menu, subtitles, playlist and other stream.
MKV to Portable Devices is the protable player video converter software that created to help you convert MKV to all the popular iPod formats such as: iPod Video, iPod Touch MPEG-4, iPod Touch, iPod Touch for TV, iPod Nano, iPod Classic, etc. with high speed and excellent sound/image quality.
MKV Editing Software is the Best Video Joiner software that created to help you join MKV files and and then convert them to other popular formats such as: MP4, H.264, AVI, MP3, WMV, WMA, FLV, MKV, MPEG-1, MPEG-2, 3GP, 3GPP, VOB, DivX, Mov, RM, RMVB, M4A, AAC, WAV, etc with high speed and excellent sound/image quality.
November 22, 2009 at 3:54pm by Fotograf Ślubny
this is a great article! fotograf zdjecia slubne and fotografia slubna bielsko Katowice krakow fine art. Psycholog on Line korzysci pomocy online fotografia dziecieca zdjecia dzieci, fotograf slubny fotografia dzieci depresja stres psycholog i pomoc psychologiczna pomoc psychologa and internetowy psycholog psychologia internetowa poradnia psychologiczna and Psychologia and psycholog online psycholog on-line pomoc psychologiczna przez Internet and psycholog online psycholog internetowy and psycholog przez internet
November 23, 2009 at 8:58pm by bodom bodom
TOD Converter Mac is a professional TOD converter to convert high definition video files captured by JVC TOD Camcorders, ie: GZ-HD7, GZ-HD3, GZ-HD5, GZ-HD6, GZ-HD30, GZ-HD40 etc. These HD files can be converted into MPG, AVI, MP4, MOV, 3GP, RM, FLV, SWF and more, which delights many JVC TOD Camcorders.
TOD File Converter Mac supports trimming, cropping and you also can add effect and special effects in synchronization with conversion. Those functions of TOD File Converter Mac could better adjust converted files to portable mediaplayers you have and make it more satisfying to your needs.
To solve the inconvinience of .TOD files, I strongly recommend you TOD Editor Mac which is all-round, multiprofile-supporting, free trial, virus-free, easy-to-use. So it is easy to understand why TOD Editor Mac is popular in JVC camcorder users.
We introduce you a powerfull Convert TOD To AVI Mac Converter, which can trim, crop tod files, add effect or special effect to tod, take snapshots from tod movie...Smoothly converting, easy-to-use, mutual-convert-supported, Convert TOD To AVI Mac can fullfill your needs.
Convert TOD To MPEG Mac enables you convert .TOD to other common formats like avi,mpg,mp4,mov that denefinitly supported by iMovie and FCP. The Converter (TOD To MPEG) uses least time and give out highoutput video quality. You can also extract audio from .Tod and take snapshots at will.
Convert TOD To MOV Mac will convert high definition video files captured by JVC TOD Camcorders, ie: GZ-HD7, GZ-HD3, GZ-HD5, GZ-HD6, GZ-HD30, GZ-HD40 etc. TOD file formats cannot usually be edited with consumer video editing programs such as Windows Movie Maker, Apple Movie or Sony Vegas but iOrgsoft TOD Converter can.
Convert TOD To MP4 Mac utility, which is powerfull TOD converter, could convert TOD to MP4 on Mac freely on your will. You can also take snapshots and store them in different image formats: jpg, bmp, png. Convert TOD To MP4 for Mac has professional editing functions like trimming, adding effects, adjusting aspect ratio, croping,etc.
Convert TOD To FLV Mac program can convert between many formats like MPG, AVI, MP4, MOV, 3GP, RM, FLV, SWF and more. Being accepted by iPod, iPhone, Apple TV, Blackberry, Gphone, PSP, Zune, Creative Zen, iRiver and any other MP4 players, Convert TOD To FLV Mac can output files with unpreceded compatibility.
December 7, 2009 at 4:29am by wonengxing131207 li
MOV Converter Mac,