RSS

Lessons in Health Care From Giorgio Armani

BY Ruben ToralMon Apr 27, 2009 at 2:57 PM

Some months ago, the International Health Tribune ran an interesting story about how some of Europe's leading luxury goods companies are shifting manufacturing from Europe to Asia. In the case of Giorgio Armani, some of their product lines are made exclusively in Asia. On the face of it, this is a totally unremarkable story--yet another company/industry outsourcing to save costs. But there is more.

Luxury goods are different from toasters and TVs. Brand cache for luxury goods is anchored, in large part, to where they are made. You expect an Armani shirt to be manufactured in Italy, not China, and a BMW manufactured in Germany, not Mexico. The same is true about Americans and health care; they expect it to be delivered in America.

Americans have accepted the reality of globalization and embraced what it has done to drive down costs in cars and computers, but not in health care… or at least not yet. In health care, attitudes are significantly less global, and that is largely an issue of perception. As John Hooks, deputy managing director at Giorgio Armani, put it, "There is no reason why you can't make good things anywhere in the world, as long as you have the artisans and the attention to quality. At the end of the day, it's about perception."

Ostensibly, Armani products are the same, regardless of where they are manufactured. Same designer, same materials, same quality control processes. The only thing that sets one product apart from the other is the "made in" label. But Dr. Gupta, the Indian born, Harvard trained specialist working in Hyderabad, is faced with the same challenge as Armani--convincing Americans that quality is not tied to geography.

How do you convince a Safeway employee and his HR director that traveling to India may not just be a cheaper option, but a better one as well? Traversing the perception gap is key to unlocking the power of global health care, or so it would seem. Studies by McKinsey, Deloitte and Mercer validate that medical offshoring is a real and credible option with the potential to generate cost savings in the billions of dollars. Despite this, employers and insurers have been slow to engage, in large part because of perception concerns.

Hooks says that manufacturing in Asia not only lowers production costs but allows Armani to spend more on fabrics and elaborate techniques that can actually improve the quality and sophistication of the final product. A convenient rationalization maybe, but most medical tourists would agree this statement. Overseas medical centers deliver a better patient experience because they can afford to spend more money on care.

This is a hard swallow for American health care. How do you protect your "world's best" image when 75 million have limited or no access to your services? Doctors are like artisans; their skill set is not confined to where they live or work. There are thousands of American trained doctors working in hundreds of American accredited medical centers that provide same quality services at half the cost BECAUSE they do not live and work in America.

Armani's approach to globalization is paradoxical. To compete globally they have to decouple their brand identity from the thing that makes their brand valuable--the "made in Italy" label. The same applies to health care in the U.S. For the U.S. to compete as a world leader in health care, it may need to rethink its "slavish obsession", as Hooks puts it, with where medical services are delivered and focus more on how those services are delivered.

The reality is that health care in America is becoming a luxury product beyond the reach of mainstream America. U.S. health care would do well to take a page from Armani's playbook and look at the opportunities that globalization offers. Changing the game, it would seem, is simply a matter of changing the mindset.

Read more of Ruben Toral's Medical Leave blog

Ruben Toral is Founder of Medeguide (www.medeguide.com) and President of the International Medical Travel Association (www.intlimta.org). He specializes in strategic consulting, branding, marketing and web platforms for the health-care and wellness industries, and is a recognized thought leader in medical tourism and health-care globalization. He is based in Bangkok, Thailand.

Related: Doctor of the Future
Related: Hello Health's Facebook-like Platform

Topics:

Technology, Ethonomics, Ruben Toral, Medical Leave, Health care, Giorgio Armani, United States, Globalization, Economic Issues, Giorgio Armani, Asia


Sign in or register to comment.
or

Recent Comments | 5 Total

April 29, 2009 at 3:53am by STEVEN TUCKER

Care abroad in centers of excellence and JCI accredited hospitals is equal to or superior to community care in the US and a fraction of the cost. Americans have already started asking "what do we get?" for the amounts they pay and the universal answer is "not much". I suspect medical outsourcing will continue to grow and specialize. It is ideal for select high volume procedures and screening programs. It won't be the way to handle chronic illness in the long run, but elective surgical cases can be done abroad by American trained doctors in JCI accredited hospitals for 70-90% lower costs. @drsteventucker

April 29, 2009 at 9:33pm by Windy Moore

Health Care has changed alot. CDHC Consumer Driven Health Care has risen into a major partner with
Insurance Firms. Alot of the world's health problems are related to restrictions. Alot of disease is
caused by malnutrition and lack of knowledge on preventative medical practices. Speaking from a
physician's viewpoint- many patients now demand the alternative treatment that they believe that
is best for them. This causes physicians to scramble to get alternative licenses in complementary
medicine. Then, physician's insurance has to cover those practices outside the realm of the establishment. Fairway is one of those insurance companies.

The problem of food distribution remains acute. A farmer from Texas commented recently in an impromtu interview that due to the policies of a major grain shipping company, small farmers can not ship food to the Third World. re: Cargill.

So, what does Armani really contribute to Healthcare in the US? The real value is helping
connect the current fasttrack innovators in foreign lands such as www.health-insights.com
The future of medicine involves the communications networks as what www.cdnetworks.com
offers in order to foster better exchange of information, medical devices, treatments, and
standards. Outsourcing will probably not go over very well, except in the realm of research
and collaborative development of pharmaceutical drugs, generic drugs already being done
at a huge discount in India, etc., and in some medical treatment applications for online medical
care. The advent of distance tools, and eventually labs that can work via the web- will facilitate
many options for more reasonable treatment. However, to have that happen- better diagnostic
information databases will have to be set up to augment what CME/Medscape is offering continuing
physicians in established and integrative medical methods, etc.
The policies of the shipping company exclusively favor the large agri-farming corporations.

May 15, 2009 at 4:48am by Brate Smith

Isnt it natural for us to believe we are healthy and not suffering from any disease ? I had a similar thought process until my physician asked me to get a heart scan done after he found that my basic cardiograms were not perfect. I discovered that there were calcium deposits in my coronary arteries and I was at a serious risk of a heart attack. I was shocked and went ahead with the Cardiologist's suggestion of an advanced iagnostic scan. Though its always tough to undergo such experiences,I was not at any kind of discomfort at the Elitehealth.com advanced heart scan facility. I am not an expert in medical appliance and machines but could feel that the equipment was world-class and I was in safe hands. That feeling is really very important for me and thats how it actually went on. The facilities for Full Body Scan were as good as they can get.

http://www.elitehealth.com/heart_scans.php