RSS Feed Not Quite Conversation

2:57 pm | 0 recommendations | 4 comments

Intern BlogOff: Firing Employees for Disparagement (Con)

| posted by Kevin Ohannessian

Here in America, we have freedom of speech. But, how free are we really? Reading about Edward Polstein, it is clear a person isn't allowed to say what they want. Some would say that a company has the right to fire employees that disparage the company. What happened to employee responsibility and whistle-blowing?

When a company's actions become unethical, or even illegal, the employees should stand up and let it be known. Even if someone is practicing the right to criticize an employee policy, like health care, it should be protected. These workers are providing a good, shedding light on something that needs to be corrected.

Nor should it matter how public the comments are. Whether they are talking to their spouse, or talking at a conference, they should be protected. It shouldn't matter if the opinion is on a note to a co-worker or on a blog. It is wrong to fire someone because they voiced an opinion. And doubly wrong if the opinion wasn't even about the company. Businesses should embrace their workers opinions and utilize them to improve the company.

How do you feel about this? Should you be fired for criticizing a new boss, or something similar?

Comment

Recent Comments | 4 Total

July 13, 2005 at 4:59pm

Wilfred Harmon Sr.

Kevin you are so wrong. You act like you are entitled to your job. You serve at the pleasure of your employer and if your presence in his company becomes unproductive(read "disparaging") then it is his right - no, his obligation - to send you packing with your sorry, anti productive tail between your legs.

Unless of course you work for the government in which case anything goes. That is why your taxes are so high, because anti productivity like you propose costs money and government employees get away with it.

Dude you need to change your attitude or go into government work.

July 14, 2005 at 7:40am

Nathaniel S

We have the freedom of speech, and along with that we have responsibility for our actions.

Nobody is denied the right to bitch and complain, but nobody is guaranteed employment, either. Just because someone is fired for disparaging his boss does not mean that he is being repressed. He was free to speak his mind, and simply suffered the consequences.

July 14, 2005 at 12:08pm

C

Great article, Kevin. I do need to disagree with Wilfred and Nathaniel, however.
You see, it all comes down to an individuals' power. Just because you do not own the particular corporation, does not mean that you lose all of your human rights. Human rights includes your right to speech without being punished.
Wilfred, it seems to me that speaking up about problems within a corporation does not spell "unproductive." In fact, just the opposite. It takes some real worthless individuals to "turn a blind eye" when confronted with ethical issues.
We live in a democracy. We choose to practice capitalism. However, the most successful individuals in this great country become that way because they have been able to vent frustrations, stand up for their beliefs, and pursue happiness. Only corrupt individuals would like to exterminate these rights.
These are very democratic rights. These are rights given by God. Wilfred, i'm not sure you want to mess with something like that! I think you should cut your losses and spend the rest of your life becoming a better person.

July 14, 2005 at 12:41pm

Jennifer Warwick

There's a difference between blogging that your employer is producing toxic waste, beating the staff, or stealing from the stockholders, or even missing a terrific opportunity in the market...and blogging that your boss has coffee breath, demonstrates poor delegation skills, or promted a golfing buddy to a job you think you deserved.

Whistle-blowing for the public good? A-OK. Genuinely wanting better for the company, its stockholders and its customers? Terrific. Publicly complaining about a workplace and co-worker eccentricities that irritate you? Knock yourself out - just be prepared to suffer the consequences.

You are not "owed" a job, and the right to free speech also includes taking responsibility for the impact of your expression.

Besides, life is short. If you have tried your best to change your attitude and/or the culture, and are still so unhappy that you find yourself becoming angry, bitter and unprofessional, then take a break from blogging angry, bitter and unprofessional things and polish your teeth, your shoes and your resume. Find a better place to work.

Comment