RSS

The Chinese Question

BY Kevin OhannessianTue Feb 14, 2006 at 3:27 PM

How's this for spin? A Chinese official today defended the country's Internet censorship practices, saying the controls don't differ much from those used in the United States or Europe (free registration required).

That statement comes as the Bush administration is reportedly turning up the heat on China to lift Internet restrictions. It also comes just a day before executives from Cisco, Google, Microsoft, and Yahoo are scheduled to appear before the House of Representatives' subcommittee on Global Human Rights to discuss their dealings with China. Those companies have agreed to censor their Web pages or provided hardware for Chinese firewalls.

The question is, how should these U.S. companies be dealing with China?

Yahoo yesterday released a statement emphasizing its commitment to open access to information and outlining its approach to some "challenging and complex questions" that come as part of doing business in places such as China. But what's the point of these grand statements of principle? Google has taken particularly harsh criticism for agreeing to censor its results because of its motto "Don't Be Evil" and because it was the sole company among the top three search engines to refuse to pass its search logs to the U.S. government.

How do you feel about companies acquiescing to Chinese censorship? Is business in China worth the ethical compromises involved?

Topics:

Management, globalization, China, United States, Google Inc., Yahoo! Inc., Censorship


Sign in or register to comment.
or

Recent Comments | 3 Total

February 14, 2006 at 4:37pm by roger fulton

OF COURSE we should be dealing with China. Anything we do over here we should be exporting, Google, Red Ryder wagons, T-shirts, Coke bottles, whatever...let them buy it. The more information they get via Google, the more they learn about us and ditto.
Get with it. If Bush wants them to open Google and see the pretty girls, so what?? The object of the game here, guys is to stop pointing pistols at each other and start selling cotton candy and Levis, RIGHT?
And, the nuclear devices are communications tools...don't think so? Did we pay a lot of attention to them BEFORE they had one? ....See?

February 14, 2006 at 7:46pm by Alexander

A quotation from one out of 370 posts from all over the world in my Open Letter to Google:

"Google owes its success to its principles. By compromising the heart of what Google means to millions of users, Google's not only abusing human rights but undermining its own brand. It's bad for everybody."

http://googlecensorship.blogspot.com/

February 15, 2006 at 9:25am by Y. John KIm

U.S. is hypocritical on the whole issue. Our government is asking for Web search log from Yahoo, MSN, and Google, while criticizing Chinese government doing the same. At this time, for a change, what Chinese government is saying is true. We should stop being hypocritical.