Fast Company iPad edition promotion


FC Member Blog

SEO Guarantees-Internet Marketing Fraud

BY Jayesh Khandor | 03-12-2009 | 6:35 AM
This blog is written by a member of our blogging community and expresses that member's views alone.
Why SEO guarantees can’t be given? The word SEO(Search Engine Optimization) is very commonly used and understood word in internet marketing.Today everyone wants to promote their website and business on internet and there for wants their sites to rank higher in search engines like Google,Yahoo and MSN.Now to help these people there are plenty of seo firms,in which some are genuine and some are not.In this blog we will target those seo firms who guarantees their client about rankings.

Why clients seek SEO guarantees?

It’s simple to understand why SEO buyers are looking for guarantees:

1. Affirmed return on investment

2. Security
Buyers who ask for SEO Guarantees are either new to the concept or have dealt with a SEO firm that gave no results at all.

What SEO Guarantees Clients Seek ?

There are two kinds of guarantees that we often come across; one
kind focus on Number One ranking and the other kinds focus on rankings
in top 5 across ALL search engines. ‘ALL’ here is an important word.
Here is a glimpse of the guarantee list:
1. Number one in Google for ‘Real Estate’

2. Get my website in atleast in top 5 or no deal

3. I have three websites, all about XYZ. I want three of them ranked in top 5 in Google, Yahoo and MSN

4. I don’t want rankings for 50 keywords, I just want rankings for
these 10 keywords – can you do it? I want a guarantee that my site
would be in top 5 across all search engines

What was interesting was that none of these demands for guarantees actually asked for a timeframe, until this one:

“I want a guarantee that my site would rank for ‘travel’ in Google
in top 10. I also want the contract to include by when you would get my
site to rank.”

The following demand was from a client who’d been fooled before by a company guaranteeing rankings:
“I know what SEO is. Just tell me if you guarantee that the site would
rank in top 5, ok top 10, in at least Google and Yahoo. I also want to
know how long would it take. I also want a guarantee that the rankings
would stay for at least 2 months.”

Why these SEO guarantees can’t be given ?

SEO firms don’t own search engines or search engine algorithms and
don’t have control over how the results are displayed and how long the
rankings would last for any site.

The SEO firms can’t realistically give the following guarantees:

1. The website would be indexed by all search engines its submitted to

a. All sites do get indexed though. They get indexed because search
engines which allow free listings want to increase their database and
give useful and new information to its users at all times. Paid search
engines obviously index sites because they are paid for it. Why SEO
firms can’t guarantee it because free search engines may take 2 – 3
weeks for indexing and also may not index a website if it has been
previously banned.

b. Interestingly, no one even asks for a guarantee for getting
indexed – it seems to be so because everyone is aware of the process.
Also, most of the times the site is already listed with search engines
due to their large database sharing model.

2. The website would rank for the keywords it is optimized for

a. Let alone top rankings, SEO firms can’t guarantee that sites
would rank in top hundred either. SEO firms do not have access to the
search engine algorithms nor does any SEO firm we know of has any kind
of partnership with any search engine that allows them to rank their
clients’ websites high in organic rankings.

b. If any firm is giving you such a guarantee, read the fine print.
We’ll be discussing a lot of such Trick Guarantees in the next article.

c. Again, this is not to say that rankings don’t come. Rankings are
achieved but purely on the basis of the Expert’s own understanding of
the algorithm and research.

Hopefully, this blog will save at least some people from SEO marketing froud.