Today's Wall Street Journal includes an excellent essay by Phred Dvorak (love that name!) about why management trends quickly fade away. (You might need an online sub.) Drawing on the expertise of management consultants and thinkers such as Thomas Davenport, the piece suggests that the biggest culprits may include:
Which do you think is the real reason? Take the Fast Company poll.
Related Stories: | Topics:Management, business development, Phred Dvorak, The Wall Street Journal, Thomas Davenport, Fast Company Magazine, Professional Services Sector |
Email
Digg
StumbleUpon
Facebook
Buzz Up!
LinkedIn
Recent Comments | 4 Total
June 28, 2006 at 5:52am by mike torvell
It is probably because most management trends are bogus hot air.
The base law of management has not changed since the dawn of humanity: incentives work.
Repackage it and try to sell it again all you want, but the reality doesn't change.
July 1, 2006 at 5:12am by M.VIDWAMS REDDY
I have a great concept to start a new business venture but this idea is suitable for big corprates.
with less investmenthuge turnovers can be attained.
pls give me one chance
July 6, 2006 at 3:07pm by Len Porzio
None of the above.
No matter how good a new idea/process is it can't succeed without an emotional commitment from those who most engage the changes to make it succeed.
Our attention spans get shorter everyday from the mere fact that the amount of information comming at us is ever on the increase.
The only way our minds can survive is to either give inadequate attention to everything or focus on the few that do matter and devide what's left of our attention over everything else.
For change to occur it must either:
A> come from the bottom and bubble up with help from managers in organizing and disseminating the information or..
B> managers must solicit the organization for their input on the issues and offer possible approaches as well as leave the door open for "Other" approaches in a true brainstorming fashion. Once the alternatives are collected and examined they then need to be presented back to the organization for a vote. This ensures there is an internal emotional commitment to making "their idea" work.
Managers and consultants think they know what's best for a company. This may or may not be true, but what is true is, arrogance on their part or apathy on the organizations part will surely kill even the best of ideas.
Emotional commitment is the key!
December 10, 2006 at 10:23am by Gordon
What about just getting back to basics and understanding human nature? Why continuously ignore, critcize and devalue the opinions of skeptics and cynics in an organization? There is great value in skepticism! It is the only real reality check. Jerome Alexander points out these values in his book "160 Degrees of Deviation: The Case for the Corporate Cynic." This is a must read - and it's a heck of alot cheaper than some goofy consultant!