RSS

Six Viral Articles to Make You a Health Care Expert

BY Chris DannenSun Aug 16, 2009 at 6:12 PM

Whether you think public-option health care is a panacea or a slippery slope, you can't deny that the issue has prompted plenty of dialogue (and, okay, invective.) Rather than keeping up on all the bloviating, here are six viral articles about the health care debate that will make you an impromptu expert.

Do we really need a public option?

This article postulates that the Obama administration might be willing to live with public co-op plans instead of a full, government-run health care option. "I think there will be a competitor to private insurers," says Katherine Sebelius, the President's secretary of health and human services. "That's really the essential part, is you don't turn over the whole new marketplace to private insurance companies and trust them to do the right thing." Below, Sebelius with Obama in April, courtesy of Reuters.

Katherine Sebelius

Learning from Europe

British Prime Minister Gordon Brown is sick of American right-wingers using his country's National Health Service as an example of socialized evil. British citizens are sick of it too--a pro-NHS Twitter campaign (#welovetheNHS) quickly became the target of so many tweets that the site had trouble handling the volume, summoning the increasingly-rare Fail Whale. Check out the Brits' take at politics.co.uk.

Nice one, Glenn Beck

There are a lot of legitimate anti-Obama health care voices, but Glenn Beck of Fox News isn't one of them. The Daily Show shows why leaving the discussion to pundits, not policy wonks, isn't a safe way to conduct a national discourse

The Daily Show With Jon StewartMon - Thurs 11p / 10c
Glenn Beck's Operation
www.thedailyshow.com

Can the market solve the problems?

Whole Foods CEO John Mackey wrote a well-considered health care op-ed in this week's Wall Street Journal. Among his proposals: end the inter-state ban on insurance sales so the market becomes nation-wide, and make individual health care tax deductible. Great ideas, but they've cost him; a Whole Foods boycott is in the works.

What about Medicare?

If you believe this NYTimes.com editorial by Paul Krugman, part of the vehement opposition to a public health care option may be an ignorance of what, exactly, constitutes a public health care option. He describes a town hall meeting in Texas where almost the entire crowd raised their hands when asked if they opposed a public option. Then the representative running the meeting asked how many of those present were on Medicare. Nearly half. (Below, protesters in New Hampshire, courtesy of Telegraph UK.

obamacare

Slow down, and do it right

The US Chamber of Commerce has spent several million dollars on TV commercials that condemn the public option. According to the Congressional Budget Office, public health care would balloon the deficit $239 billion; the CoC plans on making sure everyone knows it. Check out one of their spots below.

Listing image courtesy of Salon.com

Topics:

Leadership, Ethonomics, Magazine, seven things, Health care, obama, Glenn Beck, the daily show, Medicare, whole foods, Salon, Glenn Beck, The Daily Show, Medicare, Whole Foods Market Inc., Salon Media Group Inc.


Sign in or register to comment.
or

Recent Comments | 6 Total

August 17, 2009 at 9:27am by Jeff McSweeney

AMAZING - I love that you featured a pundit to refute a pundit to build up the validity of policy wonks.

August 17, 2009 at 10:32am by Chris Dannen

Pundits cancel each other out, like positive and negative integers. But is that what you'd really call Jon Stewart, @Jeff?

August 17, 2009 at 2:21pm by Beverlee Loat

I agree with Gordon Brown and the Brits; criticizing the Canadian system is also not appreciated.

As an American, I do hope a sound health care system will evolve out ot the debate. Created a blog to answer questions about the Canadian system, hopefully de-mystify.
http://healthcare-can.blogspot.com/

August 17, 2009 at 9:51pm by Mark Sturgell

Curious choice of six articles if the goal was to make me a "health care expert." Jon Stewart? Gimme a break. With a couple of exceptions, these were still somewhat shrill examples of all we're getting from public leaders, through open debate or in the popular media.

Health and Human Services Secretary Kathleen Sebelius is quoted as saying, "That's really the essential part, is you don't turn over the whole new marketplace to private insurance companies and trust them to do the right thing." She probably doesn't even realize that as many people don't trust the Obama administration or Democratic leaders on health care reform because they don't trust our government to "do the right thing".

But that seems to be the nature of this debate: little understanding for, or even a desire to understand, other points of view.

As for co-ops, this is a worthy idea...as long as we don't fool ourselves by limiting "duplication of services" and therefore competition and consumer choice just because it's a non-profit organization.

August 17, 2009 at 10:47pm by David Ledgerwood

I have to admit to having my head down the last few weeks with work. Thanks for the primer to get me back up to speed on various viewpoints. It's pretty funny that some people don't know what public healthcare even means. It's also hard not to love Stewart. Maybe a month off is just what this situation needs.

August 18, 2009 at 3:20am by Leah Poulton

Now this is a far more better idea. This way I can live longer! Thanks!

Resveratrol ultra