The Surprising Link Between "American Idol" And Text-To-Donate Fundraising

AT&T's text-to-vote mechanism for American Idol got Marian Croak thinking about how text messages could be used for disaster-relief efforts.

As Hurricane Katrina devastated the Gulf coast in 2005, AT&T engineer Marian Croak found inspiration for what turned out to be a very good idea from a very unlikely source.

In 2003, AT&T had helped American Idol set up a voting system that relied on text messages rather than voice calls. This was a big deal. At the time, text messaging was still new. Some 22% of respondents to a 2008 informal poll on AT&T’s website said that they learned to text in order to vote on the show.

Now, Croak thought a similar system could be used to accept donations by text message.

"I know those sound like very different situations, but you can use the same implementation for both of those," she says. Instead of conveying votes made by text message to an operator, in other words, AT&T could pass on donations made by text message to a charity. Customers would see the donation as a charge on their phone bills.

To better understand the current invention, FIG. 1 illustrates communication architecture 100, comprising an example network, e.g., a packet network such as a Voice-over Internet Protocol (VoIP) network, related to the current invention. Exemplary packet networks include Internet Protocol (IP) networks, Asynchronous Transfer Mode (ATM) networks, frame-relay networks, and the like. An IP network is broadly defined as a network that uses Internet Protocol to exchange data packets. Thus, a VoIP network or an SoIP (Service over Internet Protocol) network is considered an IP network.

AT&T filed a patent for the idea on behalf of Croak and her coinventor, Hossein Eslambolchi, in October 2005, a couple months after Hurricane Katrina. Text donations didn’t make headlines until many years later, after the 2010 Haiti earthquake, when the relief organizations collected more than $30 million in donations by text message—sent $10 at a time by texting the word "Haiti" to a specified number. Though there hasn't yet been another round of text-message fundraising that can match the Haiti campaign, text messages have established themselves as a conduit for impulse disaster-relief donations. They've also opened up a new communication channel for non-profits that aren't dealing with disasters. "A text donation is acquiring a donor, it's really not about the donation," says Jenifer Snyder, executive director of the mGive Foundation, which processes text donations for clients such as the Red Cross. "A $10 gift is interesting, but if you teach that person to love you, they're more inclined to give you future gifts. But they can't love you unless you talk with them, engage with them, and build that relationship."

Not even Croak, who is listed as an inventor on more than 120 patents, realized the impact of her invention at the time. "I didn’t think very much about that one particular patent, because it was embedded in a whole array of inventions that were happening at the time," she says, "And it’s only in hindsight that I’m happy that patent was written up."

Though it holds the patent, AT&T wasn’t necessarily the first to implement text-to-donate. Snyder says that mGive's founder was partly inspired by carrier text-to-donate campaigns for Hurricane Katrina and for the 2004 tsunami in the Indian Ocean. The organization ran its first large-scale text-to-donate campaign with the United Way during the 2008 Super Bowl.

But this isn’t the start of an ugly patent troll saga. Croak’s patent doesn’t necessarily cover every implementation of text-to-donate, and she says that AT&T is not attempting to make the patent proprietary.

Almost all phone networks collaborate with the Red Cross to pass on donations made through text messages, and many other charities, including the Salvation Army, GlobalGiving, Mercy Corps, and Save the Children, have established text-message giving programs.

"Everybody can use it," Croak says of the invention. "And I hope everybody uses it."

[Image: Flickr user Nan Palmero]

Add New Comment


  • Robert Robinson

    Hey what about local , state and federal elections ? What if congress or the white house set up a national vote text line? We the people could decide instead of our appointmented leaders. I know this would be much fairer and more efficient. We could have an answer in hours. I've been preaching this for years. It's gonna happen eventually. Lets do it !!

  • Wil

    Great article and points directly at what carrier text donations are good for ... Large disasters. They are not so great for your average fundraising efforts because of the paperwork, legal fees to get set up and other associated costs. Plus it take anywhere from 3 to 6 months before the money is actually transferred to the organization. One company we have found useful for us raising money is SinglePoint they work with nonprofits and have developed text message donations for everyone to use. It's been great for us and they were able to text enable our current 1800 number for our donors to call or text it and make a donation.

  • Gnosis Media Group

    There are many uses of SMS for social good, and I like how this person is thinking. We built an SMS based search engine called It enables users to search the web without internet access. Check it out here: