U.S. Patent Office Rejects Apple's Critical "Pinch To Zoom" Patent

The gesture patent that Apple used in its billion-dollar courtroom battle with Samsung has been ruled invalid.

U.S. patent number 7,844,915 has, in a preliminary ruling by the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office, been invalidated. The USPTO has decided that on investigation parts of the patent (which relates to iOS's most famous "pinch to zoom" multitouch gesture) were in fact contained within earlier patents. Thus Apple's patent is rendered invalid due to prior art.

This particular patent was one of the key pieces of intellectual property, of a total of six, that were at the core of the big Apple-Samsung lawsuit this year. The court ruled that Samsung was in violation of Apple's IP on these patents, and a controversial damage figure of $1 billion was decided upon. Samsung has been pressing for a retrial, recently being denied on what it says were juror problems, and is using this latest ruling to push for a reversal or material reduction in the damages fee.

How do you think the great tech war of 2012 will play out in 2013? Do you wish it were over already?

Add New Comment


  • VJB1

    Ho-ray! Its about time that the US Patent Office grew some b*lls and rescinded some of their ridiculous patents they have issued in the past!! They might even have learnt to examine more closely any patent applications from Apple!

  • John Ashley

    This doesn't mean what it appears to. For all intents and purposes, it means it's only under review. It doesn't give Apple's competitors free reign.

  • strfx4

    We understand the meaning of the word "preliminary".

    I'm sorry (or not) that you apparently feel like you just got ass-raped, iSheep.