Prince Claims Internet Is Dead, Lady Gaga Disproves It

Lady Gaga Prince

 Yesterday Lady Gaga hit 11 million followers on her Facebook page (congratulations, number 11,000,001, you get a two-minute shopping cart dash round her wardrobe). Stefani Joanne Angelina Germanotta, as she is known to her mom and dad, is not the first artist who uses social media and the Internet to push her product to consumers, but she's the consummate performer of the medium. So it's worth comparing her to Prince, who yesterday proclaimed the Internet to be "dead."

Rumors of the Internet's demise are very much exaggerated, as all of you know. We are all users and abusers of it, amusing, educating and enriching ourselves often. So is Prince's pronouncement wild posturing guaranteed to get everyone talking? Probably--he's an artist who knows the power of shock (a concept Gaga is no stranger to, either).

This is not a post to say that Gaga is right, Prince is wrong. Granted, he's got serious issues with copyright and seems to view the Internet as a milking machine that will steal your ideas, your money, and probably your girlfriend into the bargain.

So, let's delve into the on- and offline presence of both artistes.

Units Sold

Prince has sold around 100 million records worldwide, according to his Wikipedia entry. Gaga, on the other hand, has managed 15 million in album sales, and 40 million single downloads. It's taken her a couple of years to do that--Prince, on the other hand, started in 1976.

iTunes

Only the music Prince made while under contract to Warner Bros. is available on iTunes. But we know he's not a fan of the online store. "I don't see why I should give my new music to iTunes or anyone else. They won't pay me an advance for it and then they get angry when they can't get it," he said yesterday. Gaga's 40 million singles speak for themselves. Older artists, such as Pink Floyd may gripe about how their music should only be heard in album form (it's a journey, right?), but kids understand the power of a single.

YouTube

Gaga's manager has admitted that the singer's music videos are made with YouTube in mind. And no wonder, with "Bad Romance" clocking over 240 million views on the site. Interscope, the singer's record label, takes most of what little revenue comes in, from pre- and post-roll advertising, and Gaga is left with the "boring" old rest.

You are more likely to find a rainbow-farting unicorn in your cutlery drawer than a Prince music video on YouTube. He's forced YouTube to remove all kinds of content with him--after Coachella a couple years back, his lawyers protested at his cover of Radiohead's "Creep." An intervention by Thom Yorke et al. ("It's our song, let people hear it.") allowed it to go back up.

Social Media

On Facebook, compare and contrast Gaga's 11 million-plus, versus Prince's tragic community page with less than 250,000 followers. There is nothing but Prince's Wikipedia entry on it.

Gaga's got four million-plus Twitter followers (by her count). Closest we get to seeing Prince on the site is this (and it's obviously not him--I like to think he's a better speller than that, and, for a prolific artist, one tweet is not enough). He did, briefly, become a trending topic yesterday, however. A rather snarky, but very accurate tweet appeared: "Prince: 'The Internet is dead'. The Internet: 'Who?'"

After yesterday's storm, All Things D's Kara Swisher used the controversy as the peg for a thoughtful post on why the tech leaders can't work out a way to keep the talent happy. But as new media as Lady Swisha is, she forgets that some talent is very happy with the way things are. Because, if Gaga's monsters can create stuff like this that goes viral...

...compared to the sort of stuff you find when you're searching for Prince...

...then one can only feel sad that someone as dynamic and out-there as Prince once was is clinging to the idea that a small disc that reflects rainbows ("Whoah") is the only way forward.

Add New Comment

5 Comments

  • Stanford @ PushingSocial

    I still think the Purple Don is just pulling our leg. He really can't be this senile. BTW: This is how Gaga is kicking everyone's collect arse - www.PushingSocial.com

  • Scott Byorum

    This doesn't surprise me, coming from Prince. He is about as relevant as a manual typewriter and a few straws short of a draw. If you ever see "An Evening With Kevin Smith" you'll know what I mean... or just look up "Kevin Smith's Take On Prince" to get the YouTube version.

    Some people were once on the cutting edge but then get old and crotchety instead of aging gracefully. Dang kids and their newfangled Internets! It's sad but it happens.

    But on the other side of the coin, Lady Gaga could easily become a hiccup in history all too soon. Which just goes to show that this article is pretty much to do about nothing.

  • Bo Dega

    "managed 15 million in album sales" -- Prince did that in one clip with Purple Rain.
    Gaga got to 15 in a short space of time too but how long will she last? Will she be around 30 years from now?
    And how accurate were album sales statistics back in the 70s/80s?

    So has Gaga's millions of social followers really converted?

    By the way since you're on Wiki you should also look and see that he was one of the first to try to sell music online. Let me do a little work for you
    "On June 12, 2006, Prince received a Webby Lifetime Achievement Award in recognition of his "visionary" use of the Internet; Prince was the first major artist to release an entire album, 1997's Crystal Ball, exclusively on the Internet."

    Lastly, can you prove that having millions of social network followers converts to a high return in music and ticket sales?

  • JM

    I agree with you.

    Compare time and technology available the comparable also is young pop stars of today say Miley S vs. Madonna... Miley is out earning Madonna

    Artists now are from the get go getting a bigger slice of the pie now and are far exceeding earnings of their former Path Paver's..

    Princes day distribution channels, play time, formats were completely different. No on line collaborative videos, Hell NO FACEBOOK,, twitters, or live streaming from phones etc so..

    So Fast Company, Take GaGa old school, remove shock and awe Internet coverage, require to stand on music, radio, tours alone same conditions and you'll then have something to talk about.