Click here to preview the new Fast Company

Want to try out the new

If you’d like to return to the previous design, click the yellow button on the lower left corner.

Caribou vs. Starbucks: Go Big or Go Homey [UPDATE from Starbucks]

Caribou's redesign makes a claim for Starbucks's pseudo-authenticity.

Caribou Coffee

"Authentic." It's one of branding's holy grails, implying good ol' fashioned, home-spun quality, especially in tumultuous times. We've seen it everywhere, from fashion to food. Ironically, it's often the biggest companies that try to seem the smallest. Take Starbucks. It opened a stealthy, "neighborhood" café in Seattle last summer, called 15th Avenue Coffee & Tea, complete with open mic nights, poetry readings, and minimal corporate signage. 15th Avenue even boasts the trendy, super low-fi "pour over" method.

Then they shifted gears with Via, a new spin on instant coffee—the joke of the java world—and by buying up Clover, maker of those infamously expensive, high-tech brewers. Now, Starbucks is rumored to be testing an industrial-size, 32-ounce offering for its iced drinks, putting it smack in truck-stop big gulp territory. Authentic? Hardly.

Which might be why Minneapolis-based Caribou, with only 500-some locations in the U.S., a distant second to Starbucks's 11,000, has stepped in to claim the home-grown coffee crown. The brand's redesign, produced by Minneapolis neighbors Colle+McVoy, features a hand-scribbled typeface, feel-good doodles, and a friendly, cursive new logotype. It might be a bit cute, but it's a world away from their jittery, over-caffeinated, and down-right aggressive old logo—can't I sleep at all? (below, top). (Not to mention, it was weirdly similar to old-style Cherry Coke.) Plus, the new caribou is jumping to the right instead of to the left. "Into the future", Caribou says. At least they have a sense of humor.

Caribou Coffee

Caribou Coffee

[Via Brand New]

UPDATE In an email, Starbucks confirmed their new drink size, called the Trenta, but it's actually 31 ounces, not 32.

Add New Comment