Google's "Near Me Now" Tries to Kill Location-Based Smartphone Apps

Google Location

Google's just made its "near me now" facility live on iPhones and Android smartphones, with the aim of helping you find out about services near where you're standing. Clever stuff, but a lot of location-based App Makers will be furious.

According to Google's blog posting on the system, it's specifically designed to tackle two user problems: Firstly to make it easy to find out about a service--like a restaurant--that's either right in front of you or not far away. The idea is you bring up the system on Google and find out stuff like reviews made by previous customers. The quick clip below gives you a flavor of how this'll work:

The second problem Google identified was to "make searching for popular categories of nearby places really simple." That's a very broad aim, so the blog post gives the example of you emerging from the subway and suddenly having a thirst for coffee: A quick near me now search will reveal coffee shops within a short range, and you can even browse on to similar services in the "browse more categories" option.

It's all available on the Google app for iPhone and Android 2.0.1 (or later) phones with a simple click, as long as you're in the U.S.

And that all sounds very grand. But I have a problem with Google's two problems. Is it really all that hard to do this sort of thing already? Nope. There are literally a host of apps for smartphones that do this already--the "Around me" app I use is the one that most obviously comes to mind. Though they may not have Google's massive search engine running behind them, they're nonetheless capable of delivering much of this functionality already--and in a more graphically pleasing way than Google can with its tediously bland UI. And to a certain extent, I'd probably trust restaurant reviews from inside a specialist app more than the (random? pseudo-random? questionably trustworthy?) reviews that'll pop up inside a Google search. And this is just talking about basic location-aware apps, not far cleverer systems like restaurant finders inside the AR app Layar, or the social-network/game/review powers of Foursquare and Yelp.

No, sorry Google: You're telling us this is all to make things easier for users, but what you actually mean is you're making it easier for mobile-net-savvy users to stay on your site while they look for location-based data, so that you can serve up adverts to them. Oh, and let's not forget that it's a neat way for you to get hold of location data on your users so you can profile them better for your own purposes...we're not saying you're evil, Google--you just sometimes make us want to wear a tin hat.

[Via Googlemobile.blog]

Add New Comment

3 Comments

  • Guy Manningham

    Much like Wal-Mart pushing out local shops, it's the way the cookie crumbles. As long as they are making their own version and not stealing ideas, it's how the free market economy works.

  • Matthew Blaisdell

    I'm sorry, but your argument seems to be that you think Google is wrong for bringing out their own version of something that someone else has already done. By that logic, they never should have started a search engine, since there were already a couple of web search engines out there - or that they never should have started Gmail, since there were already other web-based email clients out there.

    I don't buy it. Further, I think that all of them having some competition is a good thing.

  • Lynda Neuman

    I just might try this app but first I am going to try the one you use, Around Me.